Premium hosting, support and maintenance for Australian businesses

Insights & resources

Nameservers vs DNS Records: Which One Should You Change?

Several blank wooden direction signs on a post in a forest

Nameservers decide where your domain’s DNS is managed. DNS records are the individual settings inside it that point your website, email and other services to the right place. For most jobs, such as moving a website or setting up new email, you change one or two DNS records. Change nameservers only when you want a different company to manage all of your DNS, and copy every record across first.

Key takeaways

  • Nameservers are the address of your DNS. DNS records are what’s written there.
  • Changing nameservers moves every record at once. Any record you don’t recreate stops working.
  • The classic mistake is switching nameservers for a new website and losing the email records.
  • When a provider says “point your domain to us”, ask whether they mean nameservers or specific records.

What’s the difference between nameservers and DNS records?

Think of your domain as a business listed in a directory. The nameservers tell the world which directory holds your listing. The DNS records are the details in that listing: where your website lives, where email goes and which services are allowed to send email for you.

You set nameservers at your registrar, the company you pay for the domain. The records live in a DNS “zone” at whichever company the nameservers point to. That might be your registrar, your web host or a service like Cloudflare. As Google’s Workspace help notes, the registrar isn’t always where your domain records are managed.

How nameservers and DNS records fit togetherThree layers from top to bottom. The registrar holds the domain and sets the nameservers. The nameservers point to the DNS host, where the DNS zone lives. Inside the zone, an A record points to the website, an MX record points to email, and TXT records verify services and protect email.RegistrarHolds your domain. This is where nameservers are setNameserversPoint to the DNS host that holds your zoneDNS zone at the DNS hostA record: points to your website’s serverMX records: say where your email is deliveredTXT records: verify services and protect email
Nameservers choose the DNS host. The records inside it do the real work.

Our guide to DNS records explained covers each record type in plain English, so we won’t repeat it here.

Which one should I change? A decision table

What you want to do Change this Leave alone
Move your website to a new host A record (and www CNAME) Nameservers, MX records
Move email to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace MX and TXT records Nameservers, A record
Verify a service like Google Search Console Add one TXT record Everything else
Hand all DNS to your web host or Cloudflare Nameservers, after copying every record Nothing: all records move
Transfer the domain to a new registrar Usually nothing Check where DNS is hosted first

The pattern is simple. If one service is moving, change that service’s records. If you want one company to manage everything, change the nameservers.

Older man pointing at a computer screen while helping a woman at her desk
Change only the records for the service that's moving Photo: Pexels

Why does changing nameservers take email down?

Because nameservers move the whole zone. Say a new web developer asks you to switch nameservers to their host. The new zone has an A record for the website, but nobody copied your MX records. Mail servers now ask the new DNS host where to deliver your email, find nothing, and the messages bounce or queue.

Cloudflare’s own setup guide warns that its automatic scan “is not guaranteed to find all existing DNS records” and asks you to check email records against your provider’s values (Cloudflare Docs). Any host’s import tool deserves the same caution.

Changing a single record is far more contained. When you update your MX record, all new email for your domain goes to the new provider, as Microsoft explains. Your website isn’t touched.

How do I change nameservers safely?

  1. Export every record. Screenshot or download the full zone at your current DNS host, including MX, TXT and any subdomains.
  2. Recreate them at the new host. Compare each record with your export, line by line.
  3. Turn off DNSSEC if it’s on. Cloudflare warns that changing nameservers while DNSSEC is active can make the domain unreachable.
  4. Change the nameservers at your registrar. Expect the update to take up to 24 hours to spread.
  5. Test. Load the website, send and receive email, and check any forms or online bookings.

Nameservers are public in WHOIS, along with the registrar. Our guide to domain privacy Australia covers what else a lookup shows.

Two men in a well-lit room looking at a laptop together
Export every record before you switch nameservers Photo: Pexels

Where should my DNS live?

Keep it wherever someone is actively looking after it. For many small businesses that’s the registrar or the web host. If you hold extra names from defensive domain registration, keeping them all on the same DNS host makes redirects easier to manage.

Moving hosts? Our free website migration moves the site for you, and we can check your DNS records at the same time. Our page on domain and DNS management explains how we look after domains, and you can register your domain with WMS in the same account as your hosting.

Frequently asked questions

What are nameservers?

Nameservers are the servers that hold your domain’s DNS records and answer questions about them. Your registrar lists them for your domain, usually two to four, with names like ns1.example.com. Change them and a different company answers for your domain.

Should I use my host’s nameservers or my registrar’s?

Either works. Using your host’s nameservers lets the host manage records for you. Using your registrar’s means you change records yourself when you switch hosts. What matters is that someone knows where DNS lives and keeps a copy of the records.

How long do DNS changes take?

A single record usually updates within the record’s TTL, often an hour or less. Nameserver changes can take longer, and Cloudflare says to allow up to 24 hours. Some visitors may see the old setup during that time.

My developer wants me to change nameservers. Should I?

Ask why first. If they only need the website, an A record change is enough and your email stays untouched. If they do need the nameservers, send them a full export of your current records and confirm email still works afterwards.

Sources

  1. Identify your domain registrar, Google Workspace Admin Help
  2. Change your nameservers (full setup), Cloudflare Docs
  3. Connect your domain by adding DNS records, Microsoft Learn, 2026

Want us to look after this for you?

Hosting, updates, backups and security, handled by an Australian team, so you can get back to running your business.